To keep this fair I am posting this review on both my Wordpress Blog and my Blogger Blog (that's pretty redunant, eww in more ways than one! ha ha).
I use Wordpress for my own personal site at lealaabbott.com. However, I realized the only way to fairly compare the two is to compare the web-based (developer hosted) version of Wordpress against Blogger. This is because I self-host my Wordpress site for my website and use it as the CMS system, so I have all the freedoms of editing the code etc that come with running the backend of a Wordpress site. So instead I am going to approach this as if I was a beginner to either platform.
So, lets start with the basics - Sign-up and Execute:
Ok, lightning speed with Blogger since it is integrated with Google, so if you have a Google account it doesn't take much work to then have a Blogger account. Wordpress same story, super easy you just had to go through a confirmation email. It took awhile (in Internet minutes) for the confirmation email to arrive. When it finally did (Yahoo had stuck it in the Spam folder), I was ready to get to blogging.
So getting started with Blogger. Executing a blog on Blogger was super simple. Its a little wacky navigating to the administration section, but its findable. For instance if you start from your vanity page such as http://ljascils598f08.blogspot.com you have to first go into "New Post" then you are able to see the "Dashboard" link which takes your to your administrative menu. Not liking that, kinda bad UI if you ask me. However once you get to your "Dashboard" the Admin GUI is nice and clean and easy to read and understand, the information is laid out nicely and is uniform and cohesive.
Now let's get started with Wordpress. Wow, OK, this is definitely different. I hate to admit it, but the Dashboard is really overwhelming! On the other hand, its much more intuitive to find than the Blogger admin menu. However, if you are a more experienced user all these features add up to more customization and integration opportunities. For the purposes of this section, however we are just setting up and account and executing our first blog posting. As busy as the admin GUI is it's pretty easy to find the "Write" link in the upper right-hand corner (best spot for frequently used or most important features on a website). The "Write" interface is pretty similiar to the Blogger interface with one difference, advanced options. Good for advanced users, but not so integral for beginners.
Winner of this section: Blogger
The Fun Stuff - Themes:
Ok, Worpress I think wins hands-down here with thier zillions (well 5 pages, just seems like a lot) compared with Bloggers 16 available themes. Yes you can edit the HTML, but we are talking blogging for the beginner here. My begginer persona I'm using for this does not include him/her having programming skills. Why don't you tell me which one you like better in the comments section.
Wordpress Blog: http://ljascils598f08.wordpress.com/
Winner of this section: Wordpress
Everything Else:
Yes, my persona is a beginner, but I think mod'ing out your blog isn't too difficult for this newbie to handle. So lets have a look at how you can customize in either of the two platforms.
In Blogger the "layouts" tab takes you to a part of the admin menu that allows you to change the appearance of your blog. The resutls are a pretty minimal set of tools that you can use to move around and edit your blog layout. Interestingly enough only two of the boxes you can actually move around and when you click on edit, its really a content managment settings GUI wrapped up in what you would think was the "layout editor" section of the platform. The other links are "page elements", "fonts and colors', "edit HTML" and pick new template (we already know that link isn't much fun). Well, I like the fact that you can edit the HTML, but remember my newbie persona not a programming bone in their body. So not really to exciting. "Fonts and Colors", ok midly exciting. However, "gadgets" now I could definately spend some time here. Lickety-split easy to add and I found exactly the ones I wanted right away, del.icio.us and my picture. There are tons of gadgets to choose from, they are easy to search for and a click of the button to add. This Blogger thing is pretty darn easy! Now let's take a peek at the competition.
In Worpress "Design" mode, we have the tabs "themes", "widgets", "extras" and "edit CSS". We already played around with the themes, lets have a look at the "widgets" and add a few. To keep things even, we will add the same widgets that we added to our Wordpress Blog. Wow, big difference we only have around 20 widgets we can add. I can't even add the picture widget, oh well. Now I get to the next user experience difference. In Wordpress you actually have to click on "edit" in the widget to set up your preferences as opposed to Blogger where it walked you right through it. I guess I will just have to add the "del.icio.us" widget.
Clear winner in ease of use and options: Blogger
My final opinion:
I think for a new user Blogger as a blogging platform is a much better option than Wordpress. Its easy to get started and add features and functionality. However, there is a limit to your freedoms. With Wordpress there is more freedom, but the options just aren't there to exercise that freedom. So kind of a loser there. After this little exploration I am happy to return to my self-hosted blog as that gives me all the freedoms I could ever want. However, my newbie persona is off to do some blogging on thier new Blogger blog.